Sovereign or Satellite?

“Israel has the right to defend herself,” said Joe Biden to cheers from the Jewish state. But not too strongly or for too long, apparently. When the pressure from the left wing of his party began to get uncomfortable, he issued an ultimatum. And when America says “jump,” Israel jumps.

One of the greatest mistakes Israel has made in the 73 years since its declaration of independence was to sign on as a satellite of the United States, in return for military aid. The aid has been corrosive: it gives the US too much leverage over our policies, distorts our military procurement decisions, corrupts our decision-makers, cripples our own defense industries, and damages our sovereignty. We don’t need it and we would be better off without it.

While many Americans support Israel, there are those, including some in the US Congress, Senate, and administration, who would prefer that she disappear. Even among those who support Israel, knowledge of the facts about our situation is rare. American media, with few exceptions, is at best strongly biased toward a policy of Israeli concessions that most Israelis oppose. Some of the media’s misconceptions are  risible, like their repetition that Benjamin Netanyahu is a “hardline right-winger.” Many Israelis would respond to this, “if only!”

Israel and its conflict with the Palestinian Arabs has become a highly partisan issue, with American politicians spouting nonsense in order to activate their political bases. Anti-Israel propaganda has become a large-scale industry in the US, with numerous organizations springing up, financed by our state enemies and non-state actors like the groups associated with George Soros, probably the single most prolific funder of anti-Israel initiatives.

In addition to all this, the US is currently going through a convulsive social upheaval centering on the subject of race. The mix of violence and incoherent ideologies, along with what is probably a deliberate attempt to destabilize the country, has also given rise in some segments of society (as political and economic instability always does) to antisemitism and its constant companion, misoziony, the irrational, extreme, and obsessive hatred of the Jewish state. There has been a deliberate effort by some to tie domestic racial issues like the relations between the police and black Americans to Israel. Despite the absurdity of this proposition, it has garnered a great deal of support.

Henry Kissinger once said that Israel does not have a foreign policy, only a domestic one. This is becoming true of America as well. All politics, as Daniel Moynihan said, is local. In more and more ideological localities, they don’t like us, and that has an effect on national policy.

Do we, as Israelis, want to tie our survival to the USA? Or any other great power, like China for example? I don’t think so.

But what is the alternative? Israel is a very small country with a small population in an increasingly hostile world. It is located in a very strategic spot, both physically and in the conceptual geography of much of the human race. Without allies, she would be at the mercy of much larger and stronger nations. Today she is facing a direct threat from Iran, a country with a population almost ten times greater.

The Trump Administration, whatever else can be said about it, was solidly pro-Israel. Its actions regarding Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, as well as its sharp reduction of financial support for UNRWA and the Palestinian Authority, strengthened Israel with respect to her internal and neighboring enemies. The Abraham Accords it brokered provided – for the first time – a true light at the end of the tunnel for the Israeli-Arab conflict, in a way that the cold peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan did not.

I was very optimistic at that time that Trump’s policy marked the beginning of progress away from international isolation, as well as – for the first time – an end to the artificial support for the poisonous and destructive Palestinian movement. Israel, I thought, could develop into a leader of a strong non-aligned movement, including Arab countries and possibly India, that could deter Iranian aggression. I thought that maybe the irredentist PLO and Hamas could be pushed out, and some form of Palestinian autonomy established that would both provide a better life for the Palestinians and end the plague of terrorism that has accompanied our nation since her beginnings.

Unfortunately, the Biden Administration, feeling the need to reject all things Trump, rejected his pro-Israel policy. It went back to the failed and dangerous initiative of the Obama Administration to appease Iran, a policy that guarantees a new regional war in the Middle East – one that will make the recent fracas in Gaza look like a schoolyard squabble. In addition, it is impossible for me to understand how Iran, where “death to America” is a popular slogan, will be a better ally to the US than the nascent Abraham Accords community promised to be.

Biden is a good guy. He said that Israel had the right to defend herself, and said that “until the region, says unequivocally, they acknowledge the right of Israel to exist as an independent Jewish state, there will be no peace.” He is not personally confrontational to Israel or her leaders, as Obama was. But one has to look past what politicians say at what they do. His administration is moving ahead to restart the Iran deal and resume funding the PA and UNWRA. And his ultimatum over Gaza, no matter how polite, was still an ultimatum.

I hope it will be possible for Israel to make the necessary changes to reduce its dependence on the US. It won’t be easy.

In the meantime, this week we are facing a test of our sovereignty and independence. That is the conflict over the Sheik Jarrah neighborhood. Israel’s courts have decided, after a legal struggle that continued for decades, that four Arab families who have never paid rent to the Jewish owners of the property, must be evicted from it. If the evictions are not carried out, it will establish that Israeli law does not apply in Israel when it doesn’t suit the Arabs and their international supporters.

PM Netanyahu will have a chance to prove that he is the leader of a truly sovereign and independent state in the next few days. Let’s see if he can do it.

This entry was posted in US-Israel Relations, War. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Sovereign or Satellite?

  1. sabashimon says:

    I’d be willing to lay very good odds that, once again, Bibi will fold.

  2. nudnikJR says:

    You made two comments which I would like to address.
    1. “it is impossible for me to understand how Iran, where “death to America” is a
    popular slogan, will be a better ally to the US than the nascent Abraham Accords
    community promised to be”.
    Look no further than the closet Moslem who hates America and who is presently
    the actual president of America.
    2. “Biden is a good guy”.
    Biden is a weathervane. In his 47 years in Congress he has always tacked so that he
    aligns in the direction of the prevailing wind. He will do nothing to go against the
    “progressive” wing of the Democrats.

    • David Rosenberg says:


      I think that Victor’s description of Joe Biden is pretty accurate (and hence, your comments are off base). I believe that Biden is doing what he honestly feels is best for America. He is making a mistake with respect to his Iranian policy and for some reason has brought in people who messed up in the Obama administration and is letting them mess up in his administration (which has been referred to as the OldBama or the JoeBama administration). I don’t believe that this caused by any ill intent on his part.

      I don’t know what you mean by calling Joe Biden a “closet Moslem”. He is a devote Catholic.

      Biden’s style is not to be confrontational – so he tries to maintain a respectful dialog with the “progressive” wing of the Democratic party. I wish he would be more confrontational with them. I don’t think that this is the result of trying to align his positions with the “prevailing wind”, but rather is the result of his style of working with people with whom he has to work (because they are elected members of Congress).

  3. kktex12 says:

    Good analysis. The best advice I can give Israel is to start producing their own munitions for the iron dome. You CANNOT depend on America due to the nazi demorat party. They will throw roadblocks anytime thy can into the existence of Yisrael. The judenrats are in control of that party and despise the land they cannot control. They will sell Yisrael to the highest bidder.

  4. kktex12 says:

    biden is NOT a good guy. He is as evil as it gets. He will sell the Hebrew people in Israel and anywhere on earth out to get money and power.

  5. Cassandra says:

    Victor, is your contention that Israel would be better off without US military aid an issue widely discussed by other Israelis? Do you think Israel might actually go this route at some point? Living in the US, it’s hard to tell how realistic an option it is. It sounds reasonable, and if Israel can do without the aid, it could free her up to take the actions she needs to. Of course, the US might be less willing to defend Israel if its weapons contracts dry up. What can you tell me?

    • I don’t know how widely discussed it is, but I’ve heard certainly heard it discussed and written about here. Unfortunately the IDF is more or less addicted to it, and it would be hard to disengage. It would have to be done slowly, over a number of years.
      Israel doesn’t want the US to defend her, but she wants to be able to buy whatever she needs quickly.

Comments are closed.